- Quick Summaries of Books I've Read This Year Part 3
-

roflcopter_down
- October 10th, 1:46
The Forever War
William Mandella is a peaceful borderline genius space welder who was conscripted into the military where he gets to smoke weed, say "fuck you" to his superior officers, and bang whatever random girl is assigned to his bunk that night (oh yeah, it's a co-ed military force). They are fighting against a race called the Taurans and travel at speeds close to the speed of light, which causes relativity to fuck around with time. Basically, what is months to him is decades to Earth, so by the time he finishes his training and fights (in what is an apparently pointless war where two races just kind of plink at each other in the vast depths of space) William and his girlfriend Marygay have to go back to a shithole planet. William settles down with his mother, who lives in Columbia, Maryland. He soon meets up with Marygay and joins the military again proving that a meaningless war in the cold, uncaring black of space is better than living in Columbia. He fights more completely retarded battles that basically involves both sides planting themselves on a planet then using technology to deny the other side their technology. This results in both sides fighting with technology that is only a little more advanced than sharp sticks. Meanwhile, so much time has passed for William that he is leading a platoon of people whose culture is vastly different than his. They are all clones, all of them are gay (originally this was forced on people to curb overpopulation but halfway through that's just what they got used to), and they all speak a version of English that is completely unrecognizable to William (though they have been taught William's "archaic" dialect). At this point you start getting the message that I think the author wanted to convey: War is stupid and fucks you up.
Aaaand to contrast...
Starship Troopers
You've probably seen the movie. Well, it's Juan Rico in the book, and he's from the Phillipines, not Buenos Aires. And he has no interest in Carmen other than "hey that's a pretty nice girl who's going to be a pilot." And there's no Neil Patrick Harris in the book, which was a severe oversight on Robert A. Heinlein's part. Now, if you'll think back to the movie, remember the part where all the kids were in high school and Michael Ironside is talking about how awesome fascism is? Stretch that part out a bit. Add a few more scenes like that to include classrooms once Rico has entered boot camp and after he enters officer training. Then intersperse a few of the details of live on the ship between battles to illustrate Rico's leadership style, and how he takes to the mobile infantry. And like, two battles. Oh, and remember Rico's dad, the one who didn't want him to go into the M.I.? Well, he actually lives and joins the M.I. himself. He meets up with his son and they spend half a chapter sucking each other off (not literally, but that would have been more interesting) because they're MEN now. Then Rico goes to class again. Then there's a battle. The end.
And now to address something that bothered me about the book. There's a creepy quality to Rico. He's not the strong-willed hothead that he was in the movie. As horribly acted as that movie was, the movie versions of the characters actually have more of a personality than their book counterparts. Carmen isn't even really a character, she's really just there to illustrate that women become pilots. Carl is just the eager kid who gets Rico to join and isn't heard from again. Rico himself has this blank slate "Beaver Cleaver" personality that seems to believe whatever anyone of sufficient rank tells him, and molds his own ideology to whatever today's lesson plan is (but only after offering a counterpoint to the teacher's statements, which are quickly batted down. It's clear that Rico's side of the argument is always meant to be the losing side). Rico isn't so much a character as a foil to whatever the author feels like using as a mouthpiece that chapter.
In a lot of ways, the movie is better than the book. If you just want a story with only a hint of dystopia, you can watch the movie and not have to deal with the crap from the book. If sociology is more your thing, and you want a lecture on the cost-benefits of an entire society based around its all volunteer army, then the book is for you. Each of them has its merits. The movie is mindless fun, but isn't going to win any awards. The book is thought provoking (even if you're like me and didn't agree with it at all) but gets pretty boring in parts.